Richard graphs data. They aren't models. Temperatures have been going up. I'm 61 and even I didn't follow this one iota and you asked me if I thought the planet was getting warmer or hotter I'd say hotter based simply on my memory of what winters used to be like. Does it mean the planet is getting hotter because of my opinion? No. Further, I don't know a single person who has told me they feel things are getting colder. NOT A SINGLE ONE.

So I ask you, Gene, and answer truthfully. If you knew nothing, what have you experienced? Have things gotten warmer or colder in your liftime?